The Indian government stated in court filings that Xiaomi India and its former contract manufacturer Flex did not fully disclose royalty deals until investigators intervened. The dispute involves over $150 million in back taxes and centers on whether royalty payments should be included in the value of imported phone components.

NEW DELHI — Xiaomi India and its former contract manufacturer, Flextronics Technologies India (operating as Flex), failed to fully disclose Xiaomi's royalty arrangements until Indian investigators initiated a probe, according to recent government court filings. The ongoing legal dispute involves back taxes exceeding $150 million and represents a closely watched test of how India regulates dealings between major brands and their contract manufacturing partners.

The core of the dispute stems from a Supreme Court challenge filed by Xiaomi in January. The challenge contests an Indian tax tribunal ruling which found that Xiaomi had underpaid duties in the three years prior to 2020. According to the tribunal, Xiaomi excluded royalty payments made to technology partners—ranging from 2-5%—from the total value of imported phone components. Xiaomi maintains that components are imported by its contract manufacturers separately and that these royalty payments do not attract tariffs.

In a September 21 court filing seeking the dismissal of Xiaomi's challenge, the Indian government asserted that the company was aware of the licensing arrangements under which it made royalty payments but failed to provide complete disclosures. The filing stated that Xiaomi submitted the licensing agreements only after the investigation began, supporting the government's demand for unpaid taxes and penalties.

Similarly, Flextronics Technologies India, the Indian unit of US-listed Flex, has urged the Supreme Court to quash the tax tribunal's view that contract manufacturers participated in the layering of transactions to undervalue imports. Flex maintained that it did not assist Xiaomi in undervaluing imports into India. However, in a separate September 11 filing, the Indian government countered that Flex is liable for failing to place the underlying contractual structure before customs authorities to determine correct valuations.

The outcome of this case could carry broader implications beyond the smartphone sector. Legal and industry experts note that a win for Indian authorities could lead to increased regulatory scrutiny in other manufacturing-heavy sectors, such as pharmaceuticals and automobiles, which frequently utilize similar business models with contract manufacturers.

Xiaomi holds approximately 12% of the Indian smartphone market and faces multiple regulatory headwinds. Alongside the tax demands, India's Serious Fraud Investigation Office has proposed a formal probe into alleged irregularities in its business model. Xiaomi has not commented on the proposed investigation, and neither Xiaomi nor tax authorities responded to queries regarding the latest court filings.

While Xiaomi argued during its Supreme Court proceedings that the tribunal's ruling reflected an industry-wide mistrust, the Indian government disagreed. In its filing, authorities clarified that the case against Xiaomi does not proceed upon a proposition that all contract manufacturing is impermissible.

"This case highlights the critical importance of absolute transparency and compliance in corporate governance, particularly for multinational corporations operating in India. As the regulatory environment tightens around contract manufacturing and cross-border royalty payments, businesses must ensure all underlying contractual structures and licensing agreements are fully disclosed to authorities from the outset to mitigate severe financial and legal liabilities." — Dr. Shishir Gupta, Founder & CEO, StartupLanes

Recent StartupLanes Articles

Browse through our 30 latest publications on venture capital, startups, and angel investing.