The Supreme Court of India has clarified the legal boundaries regarding lender protective covenants and participation in the Committee of Creditors during insolvency proceedings. The ruling addresses how extensive contractual rights can lead to a creditor being classified as a related party.

A recent Supreme Court judgment in the case of ECL Finance Ltd v. Abhinav Mukherjee has brought renewed attention to how protective covenants in loan documents are interpreted under insolvency law. The ruling highlights that rights negotiated across multiple documents can collectively give a lender a role in corporate policy-making, potentially resulting in exclusion from the Committee of Creditors (CoC).

The litigation involved Palm Developers, which had guaranteed borrowings by Saha Infratech. ECL Finance served as both the sole debenture holder and a separate lender. When Palm entered insolvency, ECL and IDBI Trusteeship Services were admitted to the CoC, a decision challenged by a single homebuyer. The Supreme Court ultimately upheld the exclusion of ECL and the trustee from the CoC, while clarifying several aspects of tribunal reasoning regarding financial debt and default.

The Court focused on section 5(24)(m)(i) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), which deals with association with a corporate debtor through participation in policy-making processes. The bench noted that a lender does not need to occupy the driving seat for this provision to apply; having a role in navigation is sufficient. The contractual package in this case included rights to appoint a nominee director and an observer, a binding say on board deadlocks, lender consent requirements for removing key managerial personnel, and approval mechanisms for quarterly construction budgets and escrow releases.

The judiciary observed that the cumulative effect of these substantial powers over business operations mattered more than individual clauses being labeled as standard lender protections. Furthermore, the fact that these powers had not been exercised did not render them irrelevant, as the overall framework granted supervision over policy implementation.

The ruling also addressed an assignment of debt to an asset reconstruction company made after insolvency had begun. The Supreme Court found that this specific transfer failed the test of bona fides due to its timing and forensic audit material concerning fund diversions to promoter-controlled entities. However, the Court emphasized that this finding was fact-specific and that genuine assignees of related-party debt are not automatically disqualified.

Legal and credit teams are advised to review articles, sanction letters, trust deeds, facility agreements, and powers of attorney as a single package. The judgment underscores the need for lenders to recognize the trade-off between securing extensive protective powers before default and the risk of losing voting rights in the CoC after default.

"This Supreme Court ruling serves as a vital reminder for lenders and businesses during financial structuring. While protective covenants are essential for mitigating risk, creditors must carefully evaluate how extensive operational controls can impact their standing during insolvency proceedings. Financing teams need to balance necessary safeguards with statutory definitions of related parties to avoid unexpected exclusions from decision-making bodies." — Dr. Shishir Gupta, Founder & CEO, StartupLanes

Recent StartupLanes Articles

Browse through our 30 latest publications on venture capital, startups, and angel investing.